Animals Environment Health Latest U.S.

E-mails from the Department of Health at Florida appear to be struggling to manage the toxic algae crisis

Final yr, toxic algae in the South West Florida inland waterways and the coast made it troublesome for individuals to take pleasure in our superb state, but the well being authorities answered questions that they didn’t all the time really feel in a position to answer (or need, to be trustworthy). Each residents and guests needed to know if Caloosahatchee blue crabs have been protected to eat or if it was "dangerous to breathe near the strangled channels of algae", even if they have been swimming in the Gulf.

Nevertheless, regardless of the problem, including those who despatched warning indicators, or which company adopted the disease stories, the Florida Ministry of Health remained largely behind. And quiet

And after News-Press interview requests have been refused by public register requests, News-Press acquired over 2500 e-mails from Might 25th to September 26th. Between the time that exposed: Maintain your message straight when an environmental accident deepens. “1

The team requested a record of two officials whose names appear in the rare news agencies whose department gave the situation, Kendra Goff, State Toxicologist and Head of the Environment Agency. Health and Andy Reich, scientific adviser to the office.1 The legal team of the department reviewed 2661 emails and changed sensitive information. However, (what News-Press still analyzes) shows a wide range of concerns that – more than people left more questions than answers

The following is a hard (and ongoing) job for The News-Press staff. E-mail exchange is part of how little the department works. Thank you again for the newsletter:

In August, John Calhoun, Environmental Protection Department, asked about hot zone testing: “We get a lot of calls from citizens who request without testing ponds on ponds. We usually refer to a county that directs them to a local health department who will return them to us and to our Air Department. Unfortunately, our Air business group only performs static controls on specific locations and has no hardware to perform local tests. Does DOH have the ability and ability to do such a local without testing? ”

Goff replied:“ Unfortunately, we have no chance of performing without testing, localizing or not. More information on harmful algal blooms can be directed to our website. In general, we recommend that people take precautions around waterways that may have harmful algal blooms. We are happy to continue smiling. “

Quillen stressed the health of his two young daughters, Angela Smith, who administers the Health Department of Lee & # 39; s, telling her if Sanibel Island is safe for her girls. He replied in general and gave him some informative links. They went back and forth a couple of times until Quillen was enough.

”Thanks on your answer, but you didn't reply my query. Is it protected for my household to stay in these circumstances with the blooms of these algae and this pink tide? "He wrote. "Why can't I get a direct response?"

Then Smith didn't write back.

Dagmar and Steve Martin, who reside in a lifeless finish on the Cape Coral channel, contacted the division in July. disagreeable odor of algae.

“We are permanent residents and we have no other presence,” Martins wrote. “We don't know how toxic algae are. … We hope to get help as soon as possible! ”

E-mail was decompressed into the Reich queue, but he didn't write Martins again.

August. 22, 2018, Pam Cox sent the division what he referred to as the plea “to recognize the circumstances during the Red Tide / Blue Green Algae crisis. Your site and the silence of the current state of health is a serious negligence… PLEASE, PLEASE, ask… who controls this mailbox, bring it to your other office. Don't just send an auto-reply and delete it. ”

Reich wrote back:“ Dear Cox Thank you for your email to the Florida Ministry of Health. The role of the body in responding to red tidal events is related to health problems. You will find information on the health effects of algal blooms on our website. Sincerely, Andrew Reich ”

JoEllyn Bavosa wrote on August 17 and requested,“ When do you help? When do you start testing? When do you give warnings to the public about cyanobacteria? This is no longer just a Red Tide, and it hasn't been a long time. I hope that the Agency will move forward and help. ”

Reich didn’t write Bavosa back, but he despatched his colleagues to this:“ There is really nothing we could say to show this email.

Other correspondence included:

  • Reich's answer to the question whether a flourishing region of freshly hunted alligator meat is safe to eat: “I have the best guess that toxins do not accumulate in the muscle, but without information there is no way to know for sure. ”
  • Goff tells the head of the Department of Epidemiology, Doctor Russell Eggert, July 12,“ We ​​want to discuss how we're going to handle these studies and need help. We are not used to this number of queries. “
  • Martin County, an environmental expert and former Commissioner Maggy Hurchalla, wrote:“ This is Florida's Flint, Michigan, which ignores the problem because it is too scary and difficult to handle. "
  • And with one of Goff's email rounds, Martin County Commissioner Ed Fielding apparently wrote:" It's a long, devastating summer. "

Internally, officials repeatedly stressed the need for a united front. Click here to read some of these options.

Health coach Ralph Quillen from Sanibel Island, whose red tide was at the end of August, because toxic cyanobacteria flow down the Caloosahatchee, wrote the city government – "I need to know if it's safe for my family, especially 3 and 6 year old girls living in these conditions?" [19659003] Angela Smith, who administers your health department, wrote: “We are not aware of the long-term negative effects of the red tide. Brevis affects individuals in a different way, some people experience a "red tide" while others do not. There are special questions about your family's health. “

Quillen replied,“ Hey Angela, thank you for your answer, but you didn't answer my question. Is it safe for my family to live in these conditions with the blooms of these algae and this red tide? Sanibel has over 100 children, and the island is surrounded by this poison. Should the school give filter masks? What are the long-term effects? Will this affect children's health in the future. Why can't I get a direct answer? "

Smith wrote back to tell him, among other things, that" for sensitive individuals, the use of a particulate filter mask can reduce the effects, and over-counter antihistamines reduce symptoms. "

Quillen now said she was frustrated. “Hey Angela, thank you for your answer, but I think I will ask this question again. It's yes or no. Is my family safe to live on this island? Is Air Safe? Also has Lee County been running air quality tests? Are the tests verifiable? Have you visited the island to see the destruction? … I'm looking forward to the answer. "

But then Smith never responded, even though he shocked to copy Quillen's emails up to the command chain until they reached the conclusion of the

Quillen? “The emails speak for themselves. They basically did nothing. And we have no answers yet. “

News-Press repeatedly asked the department, even when finding an email that this journalist had sent to a university professor (who did not work in the department), continued silence in the Reich queue:“ I have had time to communicate with the Florida Ministry of Health. I have asked, among other things, whether the local catch of fish observed or tested, as well as other non-fish-fish, especially blue crabs. Above all, I wanted them to tell me whether there was any epidemiological surveillance plan – or discussed – about the effects of short- and long-term human health, be it DOH, or if not, which agency

He received in spite of email, Reich did never answered him.

Other citizens who wrote were given shorter answers – if they had anything. Here are some excerpts:

11. July, 2009 Dagmar and Steve Martin from Cape Coral wrote:

“We live at the end of the canal… the smell of algae is really bad. We can't sit outside or even work in the backyard… The smell is already in the house. We are concerned about our health. It is impossible to live like this! Small children also live in the neighborhood. We are permanent residents and we have no other place. We don't know how algae are toxic. We have a dry and scratched cucumber and we believe it is associated with a bad smell. We do not know whether injured or dead fish or other wildlife. We hope we will get help as soon as possible! ”

There were no return messages in public registers The information press obtained

in August. 17, JoEllyn Bavosa wrote:

”As a resident of Florida for over 20 years, I have a huge concern to uncover that water shouldn’t be and has not been tested for cyanobacteria. Since we at the moment are in an emergency and the channels, bays and bays are full of "green mucus" and our marine life is lifeless or dying, I questioned once we are just beginning to check the cyanobacteria and toxin that it releases? I have asked an area Sarasota Health Council, and the answer was, and nonetheless is, to check solely what we have now been tested. One other concern is that county and state officers make it quite clear that the seashores are open and never closed, and "surely you can go there, even if I am not." (Sarasota City 6/16/18 video) When asked about "our officials," they refer to us at the Mote Sea, which does not even employ a cyanogen professional or your department. Cyanobacteria, as I'm positive you already know, threatened by the incontrovertible fact that we are uncovered to human health, life and water for a very long time. When do you assist? When do you start testing? When do you give warnings to the public about cyanobacteria? That is not just a Purple Tide, and it hasn't been a long time. I hope your company will transfer ahead and assist. ”

There were no return messages in public data The information press was acquired, however Reich despatched this to his colleague:“ There is nothing we could say to show this email. Andy. "

Aug. 22, Pam Cox wrote:

”This e mail is a grievance to the FL Ministry of Health group that acknowledges the circumstances of the Pink Tide / Blue Inexperienced Algae crisis. Your website and the silence of the current state of well being is a critical negligence of your department's mission "" to protect, promote and improve the health of all Florida people through integrated state, county, and community efforts ". I’ve to consider that those working in FDOH are members of communities affected by this man-made ecological catastrophe. There are numerous researchers who have studied and demonstrated well being dangers. The residents of Florida get sick and are livid that the state does nothing. I perceive that this is not a simple state of affairs, and politics plays a huge position in determining what state staff are prepared to say. Nevertheless, this drawback attacks the well being of the individuals of Florida and the FDOH must take part in it. PLEASE REQUEST REQUEST…. who controls this mailbox will deliver it forward to your different workplace. Don't ship an auto-reply and delete it. Learn my words, really feel the tears and despair that I and my colleagues Floridians know. Assist us recognize issues and stand with us by asking for consideration and funding from the state. ”

Reich wrote again:“ Dear Cox Thank you for your email to the Florida Ministry of Health. The role of the body in responding to red tidal events is related to health problems. For information on the health effects of algae blooms on our website: Sincerely, Andrew Reich ”.

Summer time is coming, and so are attainable outbreaks. Nevertheless, the Health Department has not only launched info on the cyanobacteria web page, however can also be liable for sending warning signs. So we’ve hope.

And after the last season we’d like it.


  1. News-Press

(Perform (d, s, id)
var js, fjs = d.getElementsByTagName (s) [0];
if (d.getElementById (id))
js = d.createElement (s); = id;
js.src = "//";
fjs.parentNode.insertBefore (js, fjs);
(doc, script, facebook-jssdk)) (perform (d, s, id)
var js, fjs = d.getElementsByTagName (s) [0];
if (d.getElementById (id)) returns;
js = d.createElement (s); = id;
js.src = & # 39; https: //connect.fb.internet/en_US/sdk.js#xfbml=1&model=v3.1&appId=1184360661727447&autoLogAppEvents=1&#39 ;;
fjs.parentNode.insertBefore (js, fjs);
(document, script & # 39; facebook-jssdk & # 39;))